Topic: Favorite American Idol season?

[Crazy4Kelly]

I thought that season 4 was the best because almost all of the contestants had really good talent compared to the other seasons, although season 1 had kelly.

[Joolet]

s01 was the best ofcourse, kell was in that one. lol

[Crazy4Kelly]

i knew some of ya would do that.

[SinceUbeenGone17]

yea kellys was the best season of course

[Crazy4Kelly]

i know.

[MandaElyse]

I loved season 4! I dont know why but I think I'm gonna like 5 better just by the looks of how its going so far!

[Crazy4Kelly]

i like Kellie Pickler on this new season, she reminds me of both Kelly and Carrie, lol

[Crazy4Kelly]

i hope she wins

[kc_rocksmysocks]

i liked season 4 was really cool!! it was oone of my favorites....but season 1 strted it all and it had kelly...

[Crazy4Kelly]

true

[KClovesKC]

season 1!! now with the new seasons all of them have agents. like in seasons 1 and 2 it was people who had been working joe jobs trying to make it big. like waitressing. kelly is the perfect example of what american idol contestants should be. also the newer ones are more rigged. there are american idol hate sites where they vote the worst one through all season (like scott last year, or was it 3rd season? i dont remember...) and now the judges are just becoming cruel and making decisions not on whose the best singer but who would bring in the most ratings. i think american idol has been corrupted and no other idol has even dare compare or even begin to live up to kelly's voice and achievements.

</3
Heather

[Crazy4Kelly]

that is very true

[iluvcarrie24]

i liked season 1 & 4.. because it had kelly and carrie!1 my #1 idols! i love them.. and they had some really good talent on those shows (besides the obvious awsome ones a.k.a carrie and kelly)

[Crazy4Kelly]

ya i luv them also

[Blahby the band geek =D]

i like carrie, i predicted her to win from the beginning. but kelly is still my girl!