Topic: AI?

[dontbreakawayfromkelly]

no hes from morristown, tennessee he just put that idk why but hes from tennessee. hes so hot. brooke is my favorite girl!

oh, whoops. lol
Yeah, I like Brooke but she's not my favorite.

ummm nope!
i wathced last night n ummmm
the dudes suX!
ididnt liek it they were tooo boring!

I think the girls are a little bit better but I LOVE David and the rocker (not the fake one with the blonde hair. lol. the other one who played the guitar) and the Australian guy, even though he didn't do that great last night. 

[hazel681]

which david? there are 3 of them lol! i think the guys are better than the girls! my favs were david hernandez, i love jason even though he wasnt as good, david cook, david archuleta, and robbie. australian guys is a good singer but he didnt do good last night.

[dontbreakawayfromkelly]

oh, I hate Robbie and David Hernandez!!!!
And in my book, there's only one David worth talking about and that's Archuleta! lol!

But, I must admit, the girls SUCKED tonight.  I still liked Carly, Brooke, and Ramiele but all the others bombed, I thought.  I think the rocker Amanda is going to leave and probably Alexandrea Lushington, whom, I didn't even realize was on the show until tonight! lol! No lie! She came on and I was like "WHO is that?" I didn't remember her at all and I still don't! lol!

[ericb]

I watched AI last night.I fell asleep.I couldn't help but be glad Kelly wasn't there,otherwise she'd feel like a Plummer knee deep in raw sewage. They were THAT horrible.

[juliakelly05]

yay!! Alaina's out!! hehe....i dont really like her much [no offense]

my faves this season are Brooke,Ramiele,Carly,David H and David A

[dontbreakawayfromkelly]

^ditto on everything!

But I think Amanda's gots to go!

[Lauren]

I am totally addicted to this show lol. I refuse to go out when it's on unless I record it lol
My favourites are David Cook, David Archuletta, Asia'h, Carly Smithson and Ramielle.
I also really like Amanda (Rocker Nurse) though her songs are kinda all a bit too similar by the way she sings them but I still think she's great.
I thought Jason Yeager was good (and kinda hot) and I don't think he or Alaina Whitaker deserved to go   

[Penguin Lover]

My favorite right now is David Archuletta

[hazel681]

i didnt want alaina or robbie to go.....   :'( they were good. luke should have gone home and kady should have gone home. its not fair.

[dontbreakawayfromkelly]

i didnt want alaina or robbie to go.....   :'( they were good. luke should have gone home and kady should have gone home. its not fair.

 

Luke definitely should stay! lol! He is soooo goreous!!!! ahhh. lol
But I agree-- Kady definitely should've gone home.  But I didn't like Alaina either so.  And I actually hated Robbie...did you know he wore a wig? He wanted to look more like a rocker but didn't have time to grow his hair out! Guess Simon was right about him being fake.

[hazel681]

^^i love your siggy but i disagree. You really think simon knows about rock? i dont. robbie could sing waaaaaay better than Luke. Luke cant sing well and has no personality. my opinion. not trying to argue. so what if he wears a wig? doesnt mean he's a fake.

[dontbreakawayfromkelly]

^^i love your siggy but i disagree. You really think simon knows about rock? i dont. robbie could sing waaaaaay better than Luke. Luke cant sing well and has no personality. my opinion. not trying to argue. so what if he wears a wig? doesnt mean he's a fake.

Thanks.  Well, I don't look at it the way you do, really.  I just want a variety in the top 12 and when you look at Robbie next to David Cook, the other rocker, in my eyes, David wins by a landslide because, I don't care what Simon says, he's the total package and re-creates his songs.  And technically, I do think wearing a wig just to look a certain way makes him fake.  I mean, if he had cancer or something, it'd be a totally different story.  But for my idol, I want to see him or her raw and totally comfortable with who they are-- I don't want them to put on an act for the television.  That's why I love Kelly. 

[Alicia kelly clarkson luver]

i went to the store yesterday n this lady that works there was talkin to me bout americna idol n she knew i met kelly  n she said that that kid david a when he was younger sang for kellys group at sum concert or sumthing but i didnt kno this i guesse it was shown on american idol but i didnt c it but thats so kool how he got to sing for kelly n season 1 people and now here he is singing on the actual show:) so awsoem. i like david a the best too so thats doubel awsome:)

[ToughLilCookie]

i remember the girl and the show but not the guy

[hazel681]

like i said i am glad you have a different opinion it makes things interesting, it would be boring if everyone agre. i totally agree about david cook, he wins over robbie by a landslide. to tell you the truth i like david archuleta but i hope he doesnt win, i like him but i dont because hes too innocent to sweet. i dont think he has an edge and nothing different that would make me want to get to know more about him hes like perfect and i dont like that. he needs to dirty it up a little, he needs a little growing up a little. he just needs time and i can wait.